politics
Hilton Says Sacramento Strangers Are Switching Sides — But the Numbers Tell a Different Story
Steve Hilton took a seat in the back row of a small 9/11 memorial event in Sacramento last Friday, there, he said, simply to pay his respects. He didn't expect to be working the room. But people came up anyway, the way they do at his campaign stops, and four or five of them, he said, told him nearly the same thing.
"I'm a lifelong Democrat, but I'm voting for you this year," Hilton recalled them saying, on the All-In podcast with Chamath Palihapitiya, David Sacks, David Friedberg and Jason Calacanis.
Hilton, the Republican running for California governor against Xavier Becerra, told the hosts he's heard some version of that line at airports, on the street, and backstage before events. He said it's part of a broader shift he's picked up traveling the state — he claims to have visited all 58 counties, something he said no candidate has managed in years.
He tied the sentiment to what he called the basic math of living in California now: a median home price near $1 million against a median individual salary of $65,000. "It's just completely broken," Hilton said, arguing the state that once led the nation in homeownership has priced out the people who'd buy.
The intensity, he said, isn't the usual campaign-trail well-wishing. "You have to win," is what he says he hears most — not good luck, not hope you win, but an instruction. He also said business owners tell him something similar in blunter terms: if he loses in November, they're leaving the state.
"I think this is a now-or-never election for California," Hilton told the panel.
Chamath Palihapitiya didn't let the anecdotes stand unchallenged. He noted that prediction market Polymarket has Hilton at roughly a 5% chance of winning, with public polling putting him somewhere between 8 and 20 points behind. Palihapitiya broke down the coalition math: Hilton has locked up about 89 to 90% of Republican voters, made some progress with independents at around 30%, but is pulling less than 10% of Democrats. "Aside from the anecdotal stories you're telling us," Palihapitiya said, he pressed Hilton on what changes with one debate left, on September 30th against Becerra.
Hilton didn't offer a specific debate strategy in the clip aired. He returned instead to the voters he says have grown tired of a habit — checking the Democratic box out of loyalty rather than satisfaction — that he argues has stopped delivering results they can live with.
Whether a handful of conversations at a memorial service translates into the double-digit Democratic crossover Hilton would need is, as Palihapitiya pointed out, still an open question the campaign hasn't answered with numbers. For now, it's the story Hilton is telling — one stranger at a time.
Heard on All-In with Chamath, Jason, Sacks & Friedberg — Steve Hilton & Spencer Pratt: Fixing California, Cheaper Gas, Ballot Fraud & CA Republicans (2026-09-23).
Sources
More from Talk Radio
- Radio Hosts Say Newsom's COVID Record Still Haunts Him Ahead of Any National Run
- Steve Hilton Pledges to Slash California Regulations From 420,000 to Under 200,000
- Armstrong & Getty: Newsom Would Get COVID 'Pass' From Legacy Media If He's the Nominee
- Historian Gary Gallagher: Slavery Was Thriving in 1860, Not Fading Out